Year after year, marketers spend untold hours (ahem, budget extensions) on campaigns designed to attract, nurture and convert potential customers. Yet, despite these investments, many of us are left wondering whether those arduous efforts are truly making an impact.
Ever wake up to the unscheduled mental alarm at 3 am, sounding something like: How can I be sure my email campaign resonates? Is my landing page driving conversions, or was it just the paid ads Tim set up? Should that button be purple? Green didn’t stand out enough …
If you can even remotely relate, then A/B testing has a treat (plus some extra hours’ zzz) in store for you. That way, you’re not just guessing what works; you’re getting cold, hard data showing you what drives those clicks and sales. If you’re serious about optimizing your marketing efforts, targeted A/B testing is non-negotiable.
What Is A/B Testing?
A/B testing is like a game of “spot the difference,” but instead of finding subtle visual discrepancies, you uncover what makes your audience tick. You deliver two versions of an asset — Version A and Version B — then compare them against predetermined indicators to determine which achieves your goals.
Whether it’s increasing click-through rates, conversion rate optimization or boosting user engagement, A/B testing helps identify where you’re winning and where you’re flooring. So, what can you test with the method? Practically anything that impacts your user’s experience. Here are a few examples:
- Website Pages and Functions: A/B testing allows you to test everything from your edgiest headlines to that shiny new CTA button, helping you uncover what resonates with your audience. If you’re rebuilding a landing page or adjusting navigation elements, these tests reveal which changes boost clicks, conversions and overall user engagement.
- Mobile Apps: Your app’s features and design can catch or release your audience’s attention. Experiment with different versions to learn what keeps users glued to their screens, refining your app to match your audience’s bandwidth.
- Email Campaigns: An email’s subject line, delivery timing and content can be the difference between a click and a delete. A/B testing shows what works. By experimenting with alternative variables, you can fine-tune your strategy to achieve higher open rates, click-through rates and ultimately, conversions.
For example, check out these email campaign A/B tests. Both have different subject lines with the exact same copy inside.
- Company Newsletters: A/B testing allows you to explore different newsletter formats, content types and personalization strategies. Whether you’re debating between a text-heavy format or a more visual approach, testing helps discover what keeps subscribers anticipating your next newsletter.
Overall, A/B testing comes down to making data-driven decisions. Instead of relying on gut feelings, you use real-world evidence to steer your marketing ship. And that’s a game-changer.
What Are The Advantages of A/B Testing?
So, why should you bother with A/B testing? Well, besides the fact that it can save you from making costly mistakes, it offers a plethora of advantages:
- Improving UI/UX: Small tweaks can significantly improve user experience. By running tests to analyze user behavior you can address targeted needs within your web pages, campaigns and apps. A better UX means happier users and happier users stick around.
- Optimizing campaigns: A/B testing determines what, when and how your audience wants to read. That way you can tailor your campaigns accordingly and achieve better results.
- Increasing retention: When you keep giving users the exact experiences they’re looking for, they’ll keep coming back for more.
- Driving innovation: Sometimes, the results of an A/B test can lead to breakthroughs you hadn’t considered. Any surprise findings — for example, version A nailed UX, but version B performed better in conversions — can lead to bright new solutions.
When you back your decisions with solid data, you drive your marketing efforts with precision rather than taking shots in the dark.
Subscribe to
The Content Marketer
Get weekly insights, advice and opinions about all things digital marketing.
Thanks for subscribing! Keep an eye out for a Welcome email from us shortly. If you don’t see it come through, check your spam folder and mark the email as “not spam.”
Process For A/B Testing
Now that we’ve established why A/B testing should be in your marketing kit, let’s dive into how to actually do it. To get the most out of it, you need to follow a structured process. Here’s how it works:
Performing a Test
The first step is, of course, running the test. Personalized experiments generate a 41% higher impact than generalized experiments, so assess your market and determine whether there are segments you can target. Have a think about what kind of test best serves your goals. Here are three different testing approaches to consider:
1. Split URL testing: This method tests two variations of one page to see which performs. By creating a separate URL for a landing page and rebuilding it from the ground up, you can funnel your experimental group to the modified version and compare results against your existing one. Split testing will show which page is more effective against your KPIs, while subsequent A/B tests can refine copy, images or design.
2. Multivariate testing: Want to test multiple variables at once? Multivariate testing lets you see how different elements on the same page interact, to conclude which combination of variables performs best out of all the possibilities. A multivariate test is complex but can yield incredibly detailed insights.
3. Multipage testing: Sometimes, it’s not just a single page you’re interested in. Multipage testing allows you to test a different feature or asset across a series of pages, perfect for checking the impact on an entire user journey — and ensuring users don’t bounce between different designs while you’re testing.
While we’re in the deep, you’ll want to use a testing tool that streamlines the process and gives you reliable data. Google Optimize, Optimizely and VWO offer everything from simple split tests to more advanced multivariate analysis.
But remember: Your A/B test results are only as good as the practices you follow. And if those practices look like this, you’re golden:
- Test one variable at a time to get clear results.
- Run tests long enough to gather statistically significant data. A small sample size can lead to ultimately irrelevant or inapplicable insights.
- Avoid testing during abnormal periods like holidays, which could skew your results.
Running too many variables at once, drawing conclusions too soon or ignoring external factors that could influence your outcomes won’t necessarily give you the data you need to advance and optimize your strategy.
Analyzing Results
Analyzing your results is where the purpose of your tests takes shape. Start by checking your data for trends that show statistical significance. Google Analytics analyzes page performance and web optimization data, while MailChimp or Hubspot can deliver email engagement metrics. If you struggle to understand the correlation between variant A and variant B results, tools like a statistical significance calculator can help you determine valid connections.
Next, compare your results across multiple KPIs. Don’t just look at one metric in isolation; consider how each KPI interacts with others to get a holistic view. The metrics that have statistical meaning to you depend on what you’re testing, and could include:
- Click-through rate (CTR).
- Higher conversion rate.
- Cost per conversion.
- Bounce rate.
- Time on page.
- Engagement rate.
- Return on investment (ROI).
Take note of the secondary metrics. Maybe version B didn’t win outright, but did it reduce bounce rates or improve time on the page? Secondary metrics can provide valuable insight, leading to innovative adjustments to your final strategy. Understanding the “why” rather than the “what” is where real growth begins.
Interpreting Data
Interpreting the data is where things can get tricky. In today’s world of personalized marketing, the classic “winner takes all” approach is no longer as applicable as it once was. To drive deeper meaning from your results, try:
Segmenting your Audience
Not all market segments behave the same way. What works for one group might not work for another. By analyzing how different segments respond to your tests, you can tailor your strategies and further personalize the experience.
Checking for Internal and External Variants
Sometimes, factors outside your control — like changes in the market or competitor actions — can influence the result. Be aware of these influences and adjust your interpretations accordingly.
Once you’ve gained meaningful insights from your experiments, it’s time to take action. Whether that means rolling out the optimized version to a targeted audience or running further tests to refine your data, the key is to keep moving. A/B testing is a continuous process, and the insights you gain should inform every decision you make.
Make Your Content Work For You
A/B testing is one of the most powerful tools to have at your flanks. It’s an effective way to enhance the ROI of your marketing assets. But remember, while A/B testing can offer clear insights, it’s necessary to take a multifaceted approach to derive true meaning from them.
As marketing initiatives become more complex, so do the results. This can lead to more targeted and effective innovation — if you’re willing to dig deep into the data and learn from it. So go ahead, put your content to the test, analyze the results and keep refining. Your audience — and your bottom line — will thank you for it.
